Skip to content
  • home
  • highlights
  • browse by topic
    • all nonfiction
    • fantasy
    • graphic novels
    • historical fiction
    • history
    • horror
    • literature
    • middle grade
    • mystery
    • philosophy
    • picture books
    • psychology
    • queer
    • science & nature
    • science fiction
    • suspense
    • romance
    • young adult
  • my own books
  • contact me

Hello and welcome! My name is Emma and I've been a bookseller for over a decade. I also write fantasy under the name E. M. Epps. This blog features my Two-Paragraph Book Reviews. One paragraph from me. One from the book. Here's why I keep it short.

You are here: Home > Review: “Sunshine” by Robin McKinley
Sunshine

Review: “Sunshine” by Robin McKinley

Image Emma 1 June 2011

Thumbs up for Sunshine by Robin McKinley. Fantasy.

This was recommended to me by someone whose taste I trust, as, firstly, a vampire book for someone who didn’t like vampire books, and, secondly, a Robin McKinley book for someone who didn’t like Robin McKinley (I’d read one of her books once and hated it. And no, it was not Deerskin). She was right; I enjoyed Sunshine very much and hated to put it down when I had to do irritating things like, you know, work and sleep. It’s a good story with memorable characters and a depth of creativity. However, I still cannot call myself a McKinley fan. Sunshine, for all my visceral enjoyment of it, has problems. As I read, I was reminded continually of the formula put forth in one of the few good writing books I’ve ever read: simply that 1 + 1 = 1/2. Repetition weakens. Excess weakens. The narration in Sunshine suffers severely from repeated infodumps, in which the protagonist tells us in great deal about things that are, I’m sure, interesting to the author but not at all relevant to the story. Each page, paragraph, and sentence could have lost words without loss. In short, if you are as harsh a reader as I am, you will want a red pen. But even to us harsh readers out there, I’d say: set aside the pen and enjoy the fun. (Interestingly, this was not the thing that drove me crazy in the other book of hers I read. So I will keep trying; maybe there will be a book in which all of her stars and mine will align.)

I looked around a little more. The only light was from the fire, and my dark vision was sort of half-confounded by something about this place, maybe just the thundering excess. Still, I could see a lot, and it was all pretty bizarre. The fur I was wrapped up in appeared to be real fur, long and silky, in jagged black and white stripes. I couldn’t think what animal it might be. Something that didn’t exist, perhaps, till a vampire killed it. With the slinky black shirt – and the bruises – I felt like something off the cover of this month’s Bondage and Discipline Exclusive. All I needed was ankle bracelets and a better haircut. The buttons on the back of the sofa I was lying on were tiny gargoyle faces, sticking their tongues out or poking their fingers up their noses. Every now and then they weren’t faces at all, but pairs of buttocks. The sofa was some kind of purple plush velvet…except that the shadows it laid were lavender. Well, if I could travel through nowheresville I suppose I shouldn’t protest about shadows that were lighter than their source, or about furs from animals that didn’t exist. My knowledge of natural history in black and white didn’t extend much beyond skunks and zebras anyway. Maybe it did exist, whatever it was. The fur could have been dyed, but somehow this didn’t suit my idea of vampire chic. Actually Con didn’t suit my idea of vampire chic. This hectic Gothic sensibility was a surprise. “Interesting decorating principles,” I said.


If you enjoyed this post, please share it!
Posted in book review
Tagged fantasy, thumbs up
Previous Post: Review: “What French Women Know” by Debra Ollivier
Next Post: Review: “Flow My Tears, the Policeman Said” by Philip K. Dick

Secondary Sidebar

Search the reviews….

Disclosure

My bookstore is an affiliate of Bookshop.org, so we will earn a commission if you click through my links and make a purchase. I, personally, am also an affiliate of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and will likewise make a commission if you click through those links and make a purchase. Having to use Amazon doesn’t fill me with joy, but they’re the only good affiliate program for used books available right now. So…that’s the way it is.

Copyright © 2023. Proudly Powered by WordPress & Inception Theme