Skip to content
  • home
  • highlights
  • browse by topic
    • all nonfiction
    • fantasy
    • graphic novels
    • historical fiction
    • history
    • horror
    • literature
    • middle grade
    • mystery
    • philosophy
    • picture books
    • psychology
    • queer
    • science & nature
    • science fiction
    • suspense
    • romance
    • young adult
  • my own books
  • contact me

Hello and welcome! My name is Emma and I've been a bookseller for over a decade. I also write fantasy under the name E. M. Epps. This blog features my Two-Paragraph Book Reviews. One paragraph from me. One from the book. Here's why I keep it short.

You are here: Home > Review: “The City Beautiful” by Aden Polydoros

Review: “The City Beautiful” by Aden Polydoros

Image Emma 4 July 2022

Two thumbs up for The City Beautiful by Aden Polydoros. Historical fantasy.

I have read a lot of excellent books this year but this one is in the Top 3. Alter Rosen, a young Jew in Chicago, 1893, is trying to keep his head down and raise enough money to bring his mother and sisters over from Romania. But boys from his community are disappearing—and the next one is his roommate (and crush). Therein follows a page-turning tale of (literal) spirit possession, vengeance, multiple mysteries, and young love, all set against the complicated and immaculately-drawn backdrop of the World’s Fair. This book could have been a mess, but it’s spectacularly good: you’ll feel like you’re there. You may not find that a good thing; for example, when the main characters kill a sex criminal in the lower level of a slaughterhouse and drop him into a stream of cattle viscera, I found it intensely satisfying, but read at your own risk. My one complaint is that it was packaged as YA fantasy just because the characters are young; it’s not at all that I think that it’s “too dark” to be YA, it’s that it’s not trendy enough; I think it would sell better to adults and I love it so much I don’t want readers to miss it.

I might have been his perfect enemy, but I would not be his perfect victim.


If you enjoyed this post, please share it!
Posted in book review
Tagged highlights, historical fantasy, queer, romance, thumbs up
Previous Post: Review: “The Witness for the Dead” and “The Grief of Stones” by Katherine Addison
Next Post: Review: “She Who Became the Sun” by Shelley Parker-Chan

Secondary Sidebar

Search the reviews….

Disclosure

My bookstore is an affiliate of Bookshop.org, so we will earn a commission if you click through my links and make a purchase. I, personally, am also an affiliate of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and will likewise make a commission if you click through those links and make a purchase. Having to use Amazon doesn’t fill me with joy, but they’re the only good affiliate program for used books available right now. So…that’s the way it is.

Copyright © 2023. Proudly Powered by WordPress & Inception Theme